United would pull one back as Joe Hugill capitalised on a mistake from CJ Egan-Riley, but it would prove to just be a mere consolation as we deservedly claimed the three points.
The opening exchanges were fairly tame as both teams tried to settle into the game, with City forced into an early change when Kane Taylor had to be taken off with injury after just five minutes.
But as the first half went on, City started ramping up the pressure on the visitors.
McAtee did brilliantly to control a high ball with his chest and get a shot away, but it fired straight down the throat of United keeper Matej Kovar, before the midfielder spurned a golden chance, poking wide after being played through one-on-one with the Reds keeper.
However, McAtee would get his chance at redemption after he was brought down inside the area by Will Fish, leaving the referee with no option but to point to the spot and McAtee made no mistake, calmly firing past Kovar with just over half-an-hour played.
But whilst those in attendance had a lengthy wait for the first goal, they didn't have to wait long for the second as, just two minutes later, Kovar passed the ball straight to Kayky inside the area, and the Brazilian produced a lovely curling finish into the bottom corner, doubling City's lead.
And then, just four minutes later, another mistake from United, this time from right-back Charlie Wellens, allowed Oscar Bobb in on goal, and the Norwegian rounded Kovar, passing it into an empty net to make it three before the half time break.
Following the break, we kept pushing forward in search of more goals, coming close when McAtee dinked a ball across the face of goal, just beyond a reaching Adedire Mebude.
However, it didn't all go City's way as the visitors pulled one back through striker Hugill, who slotted home after United capitalised on a mistake by City captain Egan-Riley.
In the end, it proved to be a comfortable evening for Brian Barry-Murphy's youngsters as we saw out the rest of the game to claim all three points.
HOW WE LINED UP
Kayky was named on the right hand side of an attacking midfield trio alongside McAtee and Wilson-Esbrand whilst Bobb was tasked with no.9 duties against the Red Devils.
WHAT IT MEANS
Our win moves us to just two points behind leaders West Ham United, although the Hammers do now have a game in hand over us.
It also sees us go five points clear of third-place Tottenham and fourth-place Arsenal.
The EDS' next fixture is a tough away assignment, as we will take on Chelsea.
Kick-off is 19:00 (UK) on Monday 24 January.
News about Man City v Man United
Highlights: EDS 3-1 Manchester United
Catch the best of the action from a memorable Premier League 2 triumph over Manchester United... Watch more
Full Match Replay: City EDS v Manchester United
Enjoy every kick as Manchester City's Elite Development Squad took on Manchester United at the Academy Stadium in Premier League 2 on CITY+ Watch more