Murphy was introduced at the break where nothing could separate either side in an evenly contested opening 45 minutes.
The 20-year-old was deployed in a more central attacking position behind Amalie Vangsgaard who led Villa’s line.
The hosts finally found the breakthrough at Villa Park when Mathilde Harviken headed home from close range on 76 minutes.
Murphy then had to help 10-player Villa defend after a second yellow card for Oceane Deslandes. Birmingham City pushed for an equaliser but heroic goalkeeping by Akane Okuma secured three points for Villa as they move to seventh in the table.
Four days prior, Murphy led Villa’s line for the entirety of their 4-1 loss to Liverpool in the Women’s Players Cup as she continues to tally important senior minutes on loan.
Also in the WSL, Naomi Layzell played 90 minutes for Everton as they played out a tense 0-0 stalemate for a third successive league draw.
In the WSL 2, second half substitute Codie Thomas helped Nottingham Forest extend their league unbeaten run to eight after a 1-1 draw with Leicester.
Over in the SWPL 1, Eve Annets helped Hibernian secure a 2-1 win over Hearts. It means they maintain their fourth-place spot with 22 points.