That was the dilemma presented to former City duo Trevor Sinclair and Darius Vassell on Matchday Live earlier this week.
Looking ahead to Saturday's Premier League clash away to Norwich, the conversation turned towards a memorable 6-1 win at Carrow Road in April 2012.
Tevez grabbed a hat-trick on that day, while Aguero added another two as Roberto Mancini's men ran riot in East Anglia en route to our first Premier League title.
With this in mind, Sinclair and Vassell were asked to discuss the strengths of both our former strikers, before taking on the unenviable task of deciding who they would pick out of the two.
Hear who they chose via the video above...
Norwich v City: Matchday Live
Getting under way one hour prior to kick-off, Matchday Live is our City-focused live show, broadcast ahead of each and every game involving Pep Guardiola's men.
Shaun Goater and Andy Morrison will be in the studio for our trip to East Anglia this weekend, casting their eye over proceedings and sharing their thoughts on the contest before, during and after the action.
As demonstrated by the above video, the duo will also discuss a number of interesting and insightful topics and memories.
Available on all digital platforms, Matchday Live provides a unique City-centric experience to your build-up.
Input from viewers is also actively encouraged, with the Goat and Andy answering questions throughout the live broadcast. To have your say, send a WhatsApp to: +447537186538.