Gareth Taylor's side were aiming to continue our impeccable record against the Toffees and impressive run of reaching the semi-final stages of the competition, having done so in every season since 2015.
However, our 2020 Final opponents stood in our way... Who would triumph on this occasion?
CITY+ subscribers can relive every kick of the tie via the video above.
A CITY+ subscription entitles you to watch full match replays of all Men's, Women's and selected EDS & Academy fixtures.
We are keeping the game's final result quiet in order to give fans who want to watch the full game without knowing the score in advance the chance to enjoy the re-run.
For just £1.99 per month, City+ allows subscribers to access full-match replays of all Men’s, and Women’s fixtures, as well as EDS and Academy broadcasts of selected live matches.
It also grants access to original documentaries, including the recent Ireland is Superman documentary.
Details of how to subscribe to CITY+ are available HERE.