Oscar Bobb put us ahead before a stunning strike from Salah Oulad M'Hand levelled the scores just before half-time.
City were on the front foot right from the off and could've had three goals within the opening ten minutes.
Arsenal keeper Arthur Okonkno had to save two separate efforts from Sam Edozie, before Liam Delap dragged an effort wide inside the box.
The Arsenal stopper was called into action again, making a brilliant double save, denying James McAtee's close-range free-kick, before tipping away Josh Wilson-Esbrand's follow up effort.
It looked like the goal would never come, but our persistence paid off when Delap played McAtee through after some lovely link up play. The midfielder's effort was saved, but Bobb came steaming in at the back post to convert the rebound.
However, in the closing stages of the first half, the visitors found themselves level when Oulad M'Hand unleashed an incredible 25-yard strike that left Cieran Slicker with no chance, nestling into the top corner of the City net.
The game exploded into life after the break, as we found ourselves behind after just 20 seconds when Lopez's left-footed strike went in off the post.
We weren't behind for long as five minutes later, Delap surged past the Arsenal backline and cut the ball back for O'Reilly to finish from close range.
Both teams kept driving forward to find a winner, with both Slicker and Okonkno called upon to deny Tim Akinola and Edozie respectively in the latter stages, but no winner could be found and the points were shared at the Academy Stadium.
HOW WE LINED UP
WHAT IT MEANS
The draw sees the EDS remain top of the Premier League 2, with a one-point advantage over both Brighton and Arsenal.
It also continues the side's unbeaten start to the season.
After the game, Brian Barry-Murphy said: "In the first half we created a lot of chances and their goalkeeper pulled off some really incredible saves.
"The second half was a very transitional game, we’d attack, Arsenal would attack, and I think that was down to the opponent as well.
"I don’t think we were probably at our best in terms of our play in the second half but the lads gave absolutely everything and fought right till the end.
"That mentality has been evident all season and is very important to see in every single game."
Barry-Murphy's youngsters welcome Derby County for a Premier League 2 clash at the Academy Stadium.
Kick-off is at 4pm (UK) on Saturday 2 October.
News about Man City v Arsenal
EDS v Arsenal: PL 2 ticket details
Manchester City EDS v Arsenal, Saturday 25th September 2021, 3pm Read more
Hamilton: EDS inspired by Academy first team debutants
Micah Hamilton said the sight of six of his EDS colleagues making their City first team debuts earlier this week has served as the perfect inspiration for the rest of the group. Read more